Bearings

What's actually known — not just who's biased.

China Pacific Military Assertiveness

China does not accept, recognize, or consider binding the 2016 South China Sea arbitration award, which it regards as illegal, null and void.

multiple outlets, traced to a single source · Attributed statement · first recorded Jul 13, 2:30 PM

Although several outlets carry this claim, their reporting traces back to a single shared source — so it counts as one confirmation, not several.

How each outlet reported it

CGTNChinese state media · Jul 13, 2:01 PM

The South China Sea arbitration award is illegal, null and void, and non-binding

Cites: Mao Ning, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson · Details: award rendered July 12, 2016; initiated unilaterally by Philippines

Read the original article ↗

CGTNChinese state media · Jul 13, 2:01 PM

China neither accepts nor recognizes the arbitration award

Cites: Mao Ning

Read the original article ↗

CGTNChinese state media · Jul 13, 2:01 PM

China will not accept any claim or action arising from the arbitration award

Cites: Mao Ning

Read the original article ↗

CGTNChinese state media · Jul 13, 2:01 PM

China does not accept or recognize the 2016 South China Sea arbitration 'award'

Details: 2016; South China Sea arbitration

Read the original article ↗

CGTNChinese state media · Jul 13, 2:01 PM

The 'arbitral tribunal' exceeded its authority and abused its jurisdiction; the 'award' is illegal, null and void, and has no binding force

Cites: Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson

Read the original article ↗